A buyer’s guide for compliance and audit leaders who need to decide how their plan generates, validates, and submits CMS universes.
A universe management system generates, applies CMS logic to, validates, and consolidates the universe files a Medicare health plan submits for program audits, and records how each universe was built. This guide compares four ways to run that process and gives you seven criteria to score each one.
The problemThe universe is the part of the audit your plan controls most directly
CMS asks sponsors for universes, the lists of cases in each audit area, and uses them to decide what it will test. A universe that cannot be produced again, explained, or reconciled to source systems becomes a problem of its own. In a 2015 classification memo, CMS defined an Invalid Data Submission as the condition cited when a sponsor fails to produce an accurate universe within three attempts.
Most plans do the work with a mix of SQL scripts, spreadsheets, and a few experienced analysts. That can work. The guide helps you find out whether it still works for your plan, and what it costs you when it does not.
What is insideWhat you will get from the guide
-
01
Four approaches, compared fairly.
Extend what you have, build in-house, buy a point scrubber, or buy a connected universe platform. Each includes where it works well and where it strains.
-
02
Seven evaluation criteria.
Protocol currency, data integrity, audit trail, delegated entity data, IT dependency, case workflow linkage, and operating model. Each has questions to ask and warning signs to watch for.
-
03
A cost model you fill in yourself
A formula and worksheet structure for making analyst hours, IT queue time, rework, and key-person exposure visible before you compare quotes.
-
04
A 90-day evaluation plan.
Baseline, test, and decide, with eight tests to request in any demo.
-
05
A companion scorecard.
A scoring sheet your compliance, audit, IT, security, and procurement colleagues can complete together.
Written for the people who answer for the universe
Compliance and audit leaders own the accuracy of the submission. Medicare operations, analytics, and IT teams build and maintain the process. Procurement and security reviewers need a fair basis for comparison. The guide is written so each group can see its own questions.
A position, stated plainlyNot every plan needs a new platform
A plan with one line of business, stable data, and documented scripts that more than one person can run may be well served by tightening what it has. A plan with several lines of business, delegated entity data, and a growing audit calendar usually outgrows scripts and spreadsheets. The guide helps you tell which plan you are, using your own data instead of a vendor demo.
Frequently Asked Questions
A universe management system generates, applies CMS logic to, validates, and consolidates the universe files a Medicare health plan submits to CMS for program audits, and keeps a record of how each universe was built.
Universe scrubbing is the validation of each field in a universe against CMS protocol requirements before submission, to identify missing, malformed, or inconsistent data.
It depends on the tool, so ask. Inovaare’s position is that validation should flag issues and leave source data unchanged, with corrections made by the people who own that data and recorded as decisions.
Build if you have sustained engineering capacity and want to own protocol maintenance permanently. Buy when the maintenance burden, delegated entity data, or IT queue is the constraint. The guide matches each approach to a situation.
It is an audit condition tied to an inaccurate universe. CMS’s 2015 classification memo defined it as the condition cited when a sponsor fails to produce an accurate universe within three attempts. Confirm the current definition in CMS’s audit materials.
Ready to test the criteria against your own process?
Request a universe management walkthrough to see how Inovaare’s Generator, Curator, Scrubber, and Aggregator answer each criterion in the guide. Bring your completed scorecard.
Request a universe management walkthrough →